Having seen “live” favourites, New York’s Nada Surf, a couple of times
in the last 2 years (a superlative Electric Ballroom show in support of most
recent album “You Know Who You Are” in 2016, followed by their headline slot on
the ACLU Benefit show in a chilly Boston last March) I knew that they were in
rare form, even by their own stratospherically high standards. So when I heard
they were touring the 15th Anniversary of their “breakthrough” 2002 album “Let
Go”, I could but hope there would be at least one such show this side of the
pond, even if it were London again (where Nada Surf UK shows had been pretty
much confined to, over the last 3 or 4 album tour cycles). So a Friday night
gig at the eminently accessible (even with the wanky new Bristol City Centre road
layout…!) Bristol Fleece? Hell yeah!
Pounced on tix immediately when they went on sale, and, having researched
the format of these shows (2 sets, no support; “Let Go” in its entirety for set
1 and a second, hour-long set of other stuff to follow) Rach and I headed off
early, taking the now-customary and thankfully very quiet back route to the
Fleece and nearly taking out Nada Surf frontman Matthew Caws as he crossed the
road in front of us! Luckily, he seemed not to notice... that would’ve been a gig
fail of epic proportions! Parked up, grabbed a spot down the front and chatted
away the time to ‘da Surf's prompt arrival at 7.45, Matthew immediately
strumming the acoustic opener “Blizzard Of 77” for the hushed crowd to
communally sing along.
Whilst “Let Go” might not be my favourite Nada Surf album (still a big
fan of their sophomore effort “The Proximity Effect”, and actually, aren’t
their last 2 utter corkers as well!?), I confess it marked a sea change in
their output, the moment when their initially overtly tortured and angry strumalong
US college-pop influenced oeuvre became
less frantic, fractured and angsty, developing into a more varied, irresistibly
melodic and harmonic and (dare I say) “mature” sound. So whilst rockers like
the Cheap Trick-referencing “Way You Wear Your Head”, the breathless and
tumbling “Happy Kid” and gloriously soaring and hooky “No Quick Fix” still sparkled
with youthful amphetamine pace and vim, the likes of the austere and frankly
lovely “Blonde On Blonde”, the eerie, hypnotic circular riff of the red
spotlight back-lit “Killian's Red” and melancholic wallow of “Paper Boats”
(featuring a lyrical snippet of The Bunnymen's “Ocean Rain” from Matthew in its’
building denouement) demonstrated that greater depth, providing light and shade
to the set. Also, quite apart from their almost telepathic musical understanding,
all 3 Surf dudes were good form too, Matt recounting, “we were here [at The
Fleece] once before and then we opened for The Vines [in Bristol]... Academy,
that's right...!”, dreadlocked monolith bassist Daniel suggesting it felt a bit
weird to celebrate the 15th Anniversary of their 3rd album (“maybe we’ll play
the 3rd Anniversary of our 15th!”), and elastic-limbed drummer Ira, on hearing
a “good work!” shout from some wag down the front (OK, it was me...!) following
his energetic, propulsive breaks during “Happy Kid”, replied dryly, “thanks Mum!”
The first set flew by, an object lesson in precision and musicianship. The
boys then took a bow and a brief recess, and Rach and I chatted with Julian, a
fellow Surf devotee with whom I’d rubbed shoulders on the barriers at that
Electric Ballroom show. Quickly the band took the stage again, the second set
proving to be a run-through of old favourites and some lesser-played curveballs
for good measure. Kicking off with the rousing clarion call of “Imaginary
Friends”, through the terrific, off- kilter stomp of “Teenage Dreams” and the
squalling drama of oldie “Firecracker”, this was a set for the connoisseur,
brilliantly delivered, with Matthew keeping lengthy eye contact with the front
rows throughout, again making us all feel each song was a personal gift. Some
more so than others, indeed; one enthusiastic fellow punter interrupted one of
Matthew’s intros, and was immediately rewarded with an impromptu (and almost
slightly embarrassed!) rendition of the throwaway but funny “Meow Meow Lullaby”!
Oldie “Stalemate” featured a couple of reverential verses of Joy
Division’s “Love Will Tear Us Apart” and an unexpected “Amateur” was an introspective
yet strident highlight; however set closer “See These Bones” even topped that,
the hushed opening building to a circular and absorbing climax hook, building
like steam to its conclusion. A pretty damn near perfect end to the set,
although final encore “Blankest Year” with its flippant “fuck it” party hook
and 2 false finishes sent us home in an upbeat party mood.
Well, I say “home”, but not before a signed set-list and quick chat with
the predictably besieged Matthew at the merch stand (who, laudably, announced
at the end that he’d be there afterward to sign stuff, and went straight there
from the stage). Offered congrats to this most affable of men on his recent new
arrival, before achily heading off for a nonetheless early 11 pm return home,
reflecting on the night’s events. This was a stellar performance by a band who,
for me, currently have very few peers both “live” and on record (indeed, across
the aggregate, perhaps only The Hold Steady, who of course are a far more raw
and visceral proposition, the ragged flipside to Nada Surf’s melodic
precision). Simply tremendous stuff from a very special band, and a real
celebration of “Let Go”. Even my high expectations were exceeded!