
Another very definite “double header”
here; 2 gigs in the space of 3 nights, both hosted by veteran 90’s grunge-era
dynamic guitar-heavy US alternative rock acts, celebrating the 30th
Anniversary of the release of their most commercially successful records!
Although at the time, my then-28-year old US alt-rock heart belonged to my
beloved Gigolo Aunts and their 1993 “Flippin’ Out” release, I still bought and
enjoyed both Superchunk’s “On The Mouth” and Dinosaur Jr.’s “Where You Been”,
and caught said acts “live” that year, the ‘Chunk headlining at Windsor Old
Trout (gig 246) and later appearing on the Teenage Fanclub Anson Rooms
undercard (gig 252), and Dinosaur mainman J Mascis’ noiseniks playing a dusky
Sunday evening set at that year’s Reading Festival (gig 248)! For these 30th
celebration dates, Dinosaur broke cover first, announcing 4 nights (!) at
London’s Highbury Garage, which Mascis devotee Tim was all over, getting us
both tix for night 1 before they all quickly sold out, then Superchunk followed
suit with a tour which passed through Bristol, so I hooked myself up for a trip
to Strange Brew, a new Bristolian venue on me…
Chunk was first, so I hit the road about
6.45 for a Friday drive down the M4, figuring doors at 7 so no need to rock up
earlier, right? Wrong, as it happened, as support Junk Drawer had started their
set at 7.15! However, missing half their set proved to be a lucky escape, as it
turned out; a big guy in a kaftan never bodes well for my prog/ hippy-averse
tastes, a comment about their stopping at Stonehenge on the way down from
London only serving to underline this point! Their set consisted of a mulch of
droney metronomic noise (one song briefly sounding like The Doors’ “LA Woman”
before retreating into the sonic murk), ultra-dreary soporific balladry and an
interminably long closing plod about the sky falling into the sea. Yikes!

I took a glance around this newish but
worn-in venue, a wide bar with interesting art pieces suspended from the
ceiling, and a stepped open stage which I took a spot in front of, house left,
as lead singer Mac McCaughan and his charges set up, before taking the stage at
8.30. A slightly different ‘Chunk line-up this time, shorn of Bob Mould’s
backing boys Jon Wurster and Jason Narducy (Jason himself subbing for ‘Chunk
mainstay Laura Ballance, who’s a non-toura Laura these days) and instead
featuring another Laura, hard-hitting drummer Laura King, plus Ex Hex favourite
Betsy Wright on bass. This line-up however immediately showed a more relaxed
band dynamic than their most recent UK foray, on the back of
politically-charged “What A Time To Be Alive” back in 2018 (gig 1,088). Mac
announced, “We’re Superchunk; it’s been 30 years or so, some of you weren’t
born then!”, before launching into the untitled opening squall of languid
noise. The irresistible groove of “For Tension” followed, Mac’s
few-octaves-too-high-for-comfort vocals overlaying the propulsive rhythm,
getting me rocking down the front from the outset and setting the tone for the
early set. The superb ascending riff and air-punching chorus of oldie “Seed
Toss” (which took 2 attempts to start, Laura initially playing too fast!) was an
early highlight, as it became evident that Chunk’s set tonight wasn’t a full-on
start-to-finish rendition of “On The Mouth” but rather a set spotlighting its’
key tracks…

The slower burn fire alarm blare of
“Kicked In” preceded a clattering, drum-propelled “Water Wings” and a quite
brilliant “Crossed Wires”, then the off-kilter strumalong and regimental
drumbeat of “The Question Is How Fast” built to a circling climax, oddly
bringing to mind some of The Byrds’ more psych-rock wig-outs, albeit with
swathes of growling guitar overlay. Set closer “Hyper Enough” was as frantic a
headlong tumble as ever (had NME scribe Simon Williams not referred to early
Idlewild as “sounding like a flight of stairs falling down a flight of stairs”,
he could just as easily applied that description to the ‘Chunk) before a 5 song
encore, featuring a ragged yet anthemic as ever “Slack Motherfucker” and
“Precision Auto”, another warp-speed hurtle, capped a splendid – and yes, fun –
set which proved that despite personnel changes and advancing years, the Chunk
still have it “live”. Great stuff!

Sadly I missed a list (this being a pic I took earlier), Mac instead handing
it to a fellow front-row punter, but I did get to finally meet the man after 30
years of fandom, enjoying a brief chat about Big Dipper (Mac’s Merge Records
putting out The Dippah’s “Supercluster” compilation back in 2008) before
hitting the road for a difficult and annoying M32-closure affected drive home.
Dipper vocalist Bill Goffrier was in the UK but wasn’t able to make it to this
gig; shame, that would have been something!
A hectic weekend didn’t give me much time
to relax my aching one-man Chunk moshpit limbs, and a superb family Sunday lunch
at Miller and Carter got me back home literally 10 minutes before Tim arrived
to pick me up for Dinosaur Jr.! So we caught up during a soggy drive up the
Smoke, deciding to drive the whole way in so hitting slow traffic on the A40M
but still parking up around the corner from The Garage just before doors. Grabbed
a spot near the front, house left, as the place quickly filled up with
black-jeaned US alt-rock grunge casualties, dragging out old school Dinosaur
Jr. tshirts which largely looked as if they hadn’t seen the light of day in
decades! A happy surprise about this evening’s bill was the late announcement
of Man On Man as support; the new project of Roddy Bottum, formerly of plangent
melodic 90’s rockers Imperial Teen, and his musical and life partner Joey,
their excellent “Provincetown” album is one of my favourites of this year, with
some dynamic synth propelled Stereolab-like darkwave rhythms underpinning
hushed vocals and lyrics which was all about the gay life (hence the band name,
I guess!). As if for emphasise this latter point, the two-piece (Roddy
gesticulating and arm-waving behind the keyboards, and Joey on guitar) took the
stage then shared a lengthy kiss before kicking into the irresistibly groovy
opener “Showgirls”, my favourite on the album and a deliciously metronomic
Sloan “I Am The Cancer” soundalike. Fears that they’d peaked early were however
unfounded as the rest of the set maintained that level; “Piggy” was a sleazy
grunge march, “Daddy” an eerie monotone grind(‘r) and closer “I Feel Good” was
a New Order-esque synth-laden singalong. Between numbers, Joey and particularly
Roddy were buoyant, voluble personalities, Joey asking, “do we have any gey
people in tonight? Surely there’s more than that… time to come out tonight!”
and Roddy thanking us for coming early to support the support (“do you remember
when you turned up for [a great] support band? I saw the English Beat opening
for Talking Heads…”) and preparing us for the impending Dinosaur sonic
onslaught (“you guys are in the line of fire – shit gonna get loud!”). Great
start!

We stayed in the “line of fire” as the
roadies plugged in the wall of 9 huge Marshall amps cloistered around J; then
the surprising yet unmistakeable atmospherics of Echo and the Bunnymen’s
all-time classic “Over The Wall” heralded the band onstage, J in front of us
with his cartoon baseball cap covering his back-length white hair, Murph solid
and bald, oddly resembling my father in law (!), and bassist and former Sebadoh
man Lou Barlow sporting a huge tousled mane and resembling a 70’s hair band
rocker! “We’re going to attempt to play “Where You Been”,” deadpanned J, and
the words proved prophetic, as it took 2 attempts to kick into the delirious
laze-rock of opener “Out There”; although when it did get going, it and the
slow build to huge chorus hook of follow-up “Start Choppin’” both sounded
tremendous, overlaid with J’s drowsy vocal slur and intricate yet squalling
riffery. The hurtling drone of “On The Way” was also an early highlight, Lou
preceding this by announcing, “we’re nervous! [It’s a] big London show!”
However, while nerves didn’t seem an
issue, lack of preparation subsequently did. A few of the “Where You Been”
tracks needed a couple of goes to get started, roadies constantly took to the
stage to swap huge lyric prompts around in front of J, and at one point
proceedings stopped as they didn’t have a keyboard ready for the next number, J
drawling, “we’ll have to borrow Roddy’s…” and Lou lamenting, “we’re giving our
crew a workout today…”. Also, some numbers seemed rushed and haphazard, J
attempting to make up for the shortcomings by piling on layers of hard riffery
and noise. A bit of a shame, as “Where You Been” is a fine album, fully justifying
Dinosaur’s description of “ear bleeding country”, with a definite Buffalo
Springfield/ “Sweetheart of the Rodeo”-era dusty countrified vibe, if you blast
past the grungy guitar noise…

Ironically, things improved after the
album run-through, as the band proceeded to invite a number of guests onstage.
Amazingly, first was comedian Richard Ayoade (!), looking typically awkward and
gauche as he contributed extra guitar on hard-rocking and largely instrumental
“The Lung”; then My Bloody Valentine bassist Debbie Googe provided extra
solidity (if such were needed) for a quite brilliant version of the classic
“Freak Scene”; and finally, after a cacophonous and lengthy set closer
“Gargoyle”, Primal Scream guitarist Andrew Innes and swaggering Thee Hypnotics
vocalist Jim Jones (Jones remarking, “this is a fucking treat, isn’t it?”)
joined J and Co for the savage proto psych-punk of the Stooges double “TV Eye”
and “No Fun”. At its climax, J mumbled a quick goodbye as the band departed,
following an uneven and occasionally unrehearsed, but also occasionally quite
breathtaking set of potent and powerful noisy rock. As Roddy had promised, shit
got loud, but actually it was never unbearable – quieter than a Bob Mould show,
f’rinstance!

Back to the car after another failed
set-list attempt (bah!) and home fairly promptly for 20 to 1 after speed
restrictions on the A40M hampered our egress out of town. So, overall 2
definitely worthwhile Anniversaries to celebrate; I think the consistency of
Superchunk shaded it for me, but high spots aplenty in both gigs. A fine
dynamic 90’s grungy guitar double-header!